They are apt to argue that the pertinent, all-things-considered requirement in such a case is disjunctive: Similarly, if two people are drowning and an agent is situated so that she can save either of the two but only one, few say that she is doing wrong no matter which person she saves.
Not only is it appropriate that I experience regret in these cases, but I would probably be regarded as morally lacking if I did not. Antigone, Oedipus the King, Electra. After Creon realizes that fulfilling Moral dilemas antigone order may be a mistakehe also knows that he cannot retract the ordering of her death.
He is in his sovereign right to levy such a penalty on Polyneices as a traitor, but it is a harsh and not a wise punishment, as is constantly pointed out in the play. Opponents of dilemmas will have to hold that one of the conflicting obligations takes priority.
Another example of moral struggle pertains to Creon, the king of Thebes. Thus, contrary to your view, there are some genuine moral dilemmas. She acknowledges the importance of family and savors in the knowledge of defying the state. Both supporters and opponents of moral dilemmas have major burdens to bear.
Johnny and several of his friends are riding their sleds down a narrow, seldom used street, one that intersects with a busier, although still not heavily traveled, street. Ismene declares, "I did it, yes, if only she consents, I share the guilt, the consequences too.
Fate plays an important role in Greek tragedy. The issue here is whether supporters of dilemmas can meaningfully talk about action-guidance in genuinely dilemmatic situations.
And each side must provide a general account of obligations, explaining whether none, some, or all can be overridden in particular circumstances. For instance, in telling the history of Thebes and of the war between the brothers, the Chorus brings up the story of Capaneus linean arrogant Argive who was struck down by Zeus for attacking Thebes.
John Parrish has provided a detailed history of how philosophers from Plato to Adam Smith have dealt with the issue.
These conflicts would raise no difficulties if morality required trying rather than acting, but such a view is not plausible. What if he is your own flesh and blood?
When Oedipus hears the prophecy on reaching manhood, he flees from his home to escape such a terrible fate. See Greenspan and Tessman With remorse or guilt, at least two components are present: Types of Moral Dilemmas In the literature on moral dilemmas, it is common to draw distinctions among various types of dilemmas.
The obligations generated by those roles lead Dr. How to Write a Summary of an Article? The latter are conflicts between two or more moral requirements, and neither is overridden. They were characters as well—in this case, the Chorus represents a group of Theban elders who have the memory of the past and can make important connections.
After it is prophesied that dark times lay ahead, Creon does listen to the voice of reason. He is reluctant to tell it and explains to the king he almost did not come to report what happened for fear of punishment. See, for example, Conee and Zimmerman Regret can even be appropriate when a person has no causal connection at all with the bad state of affairs.
Polyneices is to be left unburied, prey to the animals as an example to traitors. Matters are even more complicated, though, as the second objection to the argument from moral residue shows. Responses to the Arguments Now obviously the inconsistency in the first argument can be avoided if one denies either PC or PD.
He says that a ruler is only proved by his lawgiving, and he believes he shows his impartiality by choosing the good of Thebes over his kinship to Polyneices. Although this same cognitive component is not part of regret, the negative feeling is.
A constant battle between man and the gods are apparent, and the concepts of burial rights are similarly played out.
The pursuit of wisdom leads to happiness, as Antigone tells us. So, did Antigone ultimately succeed in this moral quest to stand by the value of Greek mythology, despite her suicide? Thus, they bring out the moral that will apply to Creon as well:9 Moral Dilemmas That Will Break Your Brain.
Take this poll to see how your answers to these classic moral dilemmas compare to everyone else's. Are we all terrible people?! The moral dilemma of which law should take precedence, sacred law or human law, is announced in the opening discussion between the sisters, Antigone and Ismene.
Ismene says, “I yield to those who have authority” (line 67). I don't like the word moral in this context. This isn't so much a lesson in what one should or should not do. The theme is inspiring though. Creon has ordered Polynices to rot in an unsanctified hole somewhere while Eteocles gets a pretty snazzy burial.
Antigone refuses to let Polynices to rot. Oct 13, · Antigone is full of moral dilemmas that stretch and pull the characters in different directions.
Almost every character has trouble drawing the line between right and wrong. For instance, right in the beginning we see Antigone and Ismene discussing the morality surrounding their brother's mi-centre.com: reynoldsjm. The struggle between human law and divine law is a moral dilemma Antigone feels as she decides to go against the laws of the king.
Antigone’s desire to bury Polyneices properly according a divine edict is challenged as she faces the hurdle to defy King Creon’s ruling. Antigone’s Moral Dilemma Perhaps the most pronounced question in the play “Antigone” by Sophocles’ is the value of human law vs.